What is creative hopelessness?

Creative hopelessness is a term used in acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) that refers to the process of recognising and accepting the limitations of traditional strategies to control or avoid emotional pain. It involves embracing the understanding that trying to eliminate or suppress difficult thoughts and emotions often leads to more suffering. It encourages individuals to explore new ways of relating to their internal experiences and improving psychological flexibility. In traditional problem-solving approaches, the emphasis is often on finding solutions to problems or eliminating difficulties. However, in creative hopelessness, the focus shifts towards accepting the presence of suffering or challenging experiences as an inherent part of life. It involves acknowledging that certain problems may not have immediate solutions or may be beyond our control. Rather than struggling against or avoiding difficult emotions, thoughts, or circumstances, creative hopelessness encourages individuals to develop a different relationship with them. It involves embracing the reality of the situation and adopting a more flexible and open mindset.

Creative hopelessness and ACT

Within the framework of ACT, the concept of creative hopelessness often raises eyebrows and triggers misunderstandings. The term itself may seem contradictory, but it serves a powerful purpose in helping clients find new ways to approach their problems. Let’s explore the significance of “creative” in creative hopelessness and how it can lead to transformative change

“Why is it creative?”

The “creative” aspect of creative hopelessness refers to exploring alternative ways of relating to difficulties. By acknowledging and accepting the limitations and uncertainties of life, individuals can tap into their creativity and find new ways of responding to challenges. This may involve shifting their perspective, changing their behaviour, or finding new meaning and purpose in their lives.

“Why is it hopeless?”

Creative hopelessness is not about giving up or resigning oneself to a life of suffering. Instead, it is about recognising that struggling against certain aspects of life may be futile and counterproductive. Or another way to put it is that they are hopeless and won’t achieve the desired result. By accepting the presence of difficulties, and letting go of “hopeless” or unworkable control strategies, individuals can free up energy and focus on what truly matters to them, making choices that align with their values and pursuing a meaningful life despite the challenges they may face.

Navigating the control agenda

At the beginning of therapy, the control agenda tends to dominate clients’ thoughts and actions. For instance, someone grappling with high levels of anxiety may be solely focused on eliminating their distress as quickly as possible. Whilst this instinct is understandable, it’s important to recognise that excessive control often contributes to the problem itself. As practitioners, we face the challenge of validating clients’ need to reduce their distress while simultaneously guiding them away from reinforcing unhelpful behaviours. This is where creative hopelessness comes into play.

Utilising metaphors

Metaphors are powerful tools for conveying knowledge and experiences across different domains of life. Metaphors such as the Chinese Finger Traps and the Tug of War, highlight the futility of struggle. Another metaphor that can be useful is the Person in the Hole:

Imagine walking through life when suddenly, through no fault of your own, you stumble into a deep, dark hole. Understandably, panic sets in, and you reach for a shovel in search of a way out. Instinctively, you start digging, thinking it’s the right course of action. However, digging only exacerbates the problem because it creates more holes. Counterintuitively, the first step towards a solution is to stop digging and drop the shovel, even when it feels satisfying to take immediate action.

Contrasting short-term and long-term effectiveness

Control strategies often appeal to us because they seem to work, at least in the short-term. They provide a sense of taking action and avoiding passivity. It’s crucial to acknowledge and validate these functions. However, we must also contrast short-term effectiveness with the limitations that emerge in the long run. By doing so, clients can develop a sense of hopelessness regarding their current strategies. Care must be taken not to imply that the practitioner possesses a secret, all-powerful tool. Instead, we need to help clients recognise that their previous approaches are merely different forms of digging, leading to the realisation that genuine creativity and innovation are necessary for progress.

By embracing the idea of creative hopelessness, clients can break free from the constraints of their control agenda and discover new possibilities. Metaphors and the contrast between short-term and long-term effectiveness play crucial roles in facilitating this transformative process. As practitioners, it is our privilege to guide clients towards embracing creative hopelessness, empowering them to embark on a path of growth and change.

A handy way to go through creative hopelessness is to use our free to download workability worksheet. It provides a step by step guide to the 5 workability questions.

If you want to learn more about workability and creative hopelessness, check out our on-demand training, Getting unstuck and working with resistance: a practical guide to using creative hopelessness in ACT, with Dr Joe Oliver. In this training, Joe gives you a practical overview of how to use creative hopelessness in your sessions to manage resistance and increase commitment to behavioural change.

Resources related to Creative hopelessness and ACTACTivate your life: An ACT Workbook

ACTivate Your Life: An Acceptance and Commitment Therapy Workbook for …

Read more